This article exposes the fundamental flaws of the Climate Overshoot Commission and its report, including how it attempts to legitimise and normalise solar geoengineering, under the guise and pretence of ‘neutrality’. The Climate Overshoot Commission was heavily criticised by both civil society, academics and several members and youth associated with the Commission – several whom decided to resign. While presenting itself with the appearance of a UN body (even mimicking the UNFCCC logo), the Commission was populated and run by pro-geoengineers from its very start.